Communities Urgent Warning Ahead of Vale S.A.’s Annual Meeting: Stop Ongoing Abuses of People and Environment
As shareholders in Brazilian mining giant Vale S.A prepare to gather online for the company’s Annual General Meeting (AGM), communities from Brazil to Indonesia criticize the company’s track record on human rights and environmental stewardship. They also point to the almost $50 billion in mounting lawsuits against the company as a risk factor that should serve as a warning sign to investors.
Communities have tried to dialogue with investors to warn them of Vale’s refusal to adhere to higher mining safety standards, to implement measures to mitigate risks from their operations, and to adequately remedy the harms already caused by the company in Brazil and abroad. In 2024, communities and their international allies invited 79 investors to visit Brumadinho, Brazil, to see Vale’s impacts firsthand, however, none accepted the invitation.
Communities and civil society will participate in the AGM tomorrow and listen to the shareholders’ concerns and questions regarding Vale’s Management Report and Financial statements. They call on shareholders to work with impacted communities to take action on the risks raised during the meeting.
In the five years since the collapse of Vale’s tailings dam in Brumadinho, which killed 272 people and unleashed 12 million cubic meters of ore tailing into the surrounding areas, the company has focused on repairing its public image. Vale sells itself as a socially and environmentally responsible company, both in Brazil and abroad by claiming to have learned from the mistakes of the past, and by stating that it is committed to life, to nature and to international principles and standards of good practice and sustainability.
However, communities impacted by Vale’s operations around the globe tell a different story. Communities downstream from Vale’s mines continue to experience human rights abuses, environmental degradation, workers rights violations, and trauma as a result of Vale’s actions.
“Communities and other stakeholders are speaking up about the ongoing Vale’s social and environmental impacts, highlighting the contradictions between the narrative created by the company for investors and the reality on the ground. Investors must go beyond Vale’s reports to have a full picture and must take action to hold the company accountable for the past and ongoing damages,” said Fernanda Martins from the International Network of People Affected by Vale (AIAAV, in Portuguese), a network that brings together different stakeholders, including communities, NGOs, community-based associations, religious groups, workers, trade unionists, environmentalists, academics, and human rights defenders.
Brumadinho is not alone in facing these impacts in Brazil. Vale manages 27 mining dams currently operating under emergency protocols in the state of Minas Gerais, with 2 dams categorized as at imminent risk of rupture. As a result, hundreds of families have been uprooted from their homes and there are almost one thousand families still living in temporary rented accommodations, away from their relatives, neighbors, pets and livestock, with no land to carry out their subsistence farming. As families wait, Vale was fined 46 million dollars for failing the legal deadline to decommission all upstream mining dams by 2022, with decommission plans extending the local population’s safety risks to 2035.
In Indonesia, communities contend Vale’s nickel mining operations provide a potential threat to the existence of rainforests, as well as the livelihoods of thousands of women living off pepper farming in Loeha Raya, Sulawesi. They also warn about the environmental impacts from water contamination at already existing operations in the area. The community has criticized Vale Indonesia for not being transparent, citing the fact they have never been given information about Vale Indonesia's nickel mine expansion plan in the Tanamalia Block.
Last year, the community in Loeha Raya had asked the shareholders of Vale Indonesia to remove the Tanamalia block, which includes more than 3000 hectares of pepper plantations, from Vale's mining concession. In addition, the block is a rainforest landscape that has essential ecological functions and is home to Sulawesi's endemic flora and fauna.
“This year, thousands of residents in Loeha are still very hopeful that Vale Indonesia's nickel mine expansion plan will not destroy the rainforest and displace the community's peppercorn plantations,” said Muhammad Al Amin of Executive Director of Wahana Lingkungan Hidup Indonesia (WALHI) South Sulawesi. “We hope that Vale and all its shareholders will respect the community's wishes to avoid conflict and greater environmental impacts.”
Vale S.A. is facing an ever increasing number of lawsuits and fines for their role in the tailings dam failures in Mariana and Brumadinho. In 2022, Brazilian Office of the Comptroller General (CGU) fined the company over $17 million for the company's interference with the Brumadinho dam inspection. In 2023, Vale S.A. agreed to pay $ 55.9 million to settle the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) case for false and misleading disclosures in public sustainability reports. In 2024, a Brazilian judge ordered Vale to pay $9.67 billion for damages from the Mariana tailings dam failure, and there are two pending lawsuits regarding compensation for the Mariana failure in the United Kingdom ($46 Billion) and The Netherlands ($3.8 Billion).
Several investors have already acted on their concern for the risks associated with Vale. Data from the Financial Exclusions Tracker website indicate that 48 pension funds and institutional investors worldwide have blacklisted Vale.
“The ongoing lawsuits and administrative fines put Vale in a precarious situation. Investors should understand that these lawsuits are indicators that Vale hasn’t handled its ESG responsibilities appropriately,” said Ana Xambre Pereira from the Dutch organization Both Ends. “Almost 10 years after the Mariana tailings dam failure, which killed 19 people and spilled 60 million cubic meters of ore tailings, two pending international lawsuits seek proper compensation for the victims. The recent lawsuit filed in the Netherlands might indicate that other cases are pending. There is a high litigation risk for the Brumadinho tragedy in time.”
Partners:
Both ENDS, Eerlijke geldwijzer, AIAAV, Instituto Corilheira, Earthworks, Walhi, Terre Solidaire, ECCHR, Facing Finance, Misereor, Banktrack
Read more about this subject
-
News / 16 November 2023
Voting with a worldwide impact
Disposable fashion items continue to flood into the country, the nitrogen crisis has brought construction to a standstill and energy poverty is on the rise, but Dutch politicians are contemplating their navels. These are problems that we can never solve on our own. The clothes we wear, the food on our plates, and the electricity that comes out of our wall sockets – they are all produced in global trade and production chains. With far-reaching consequences, both in our own country and far, very far beyond our borders. It would be naive to think that we can solve all these problems through domestic policies alone. And vice versa: we would be evading our responsibilities if we continued to believe that the Netherlands only plays a humble role on the global stage. Latest figures show that the Netherlands is the fourth largest exporter and the seventh largest importer of products worldwide. With the elections on the way, it is time to look beyond our own small country. Because it is also important to vote with a worldwide impact.
-
News / 13 November 2023
Recommendations to the foreign financiers of Argentina's lithium rush
To realise the energy transition, large quantities of minerals and metals such as lithium, cobalt and rare earth metals are needed. These raw materials are mainly extracted in countries in the global South, and unfortunately this is almost always accompanied by human rights violations and environmental destruction. Today – also in light of EU Raw Materials Week that is happening this week – Argentinian organisation FARN and Both ENDS publish a joint report on the extraction of lithium in Argentina.
-
Publication / 13 November 2023
-
Event / 9 November 2023, 20:30 - 22:30
Election debate: The Netherlands in the world
See the Dutch web page for more information (in Dutch).
-
Publication / 30 October 2023
-
Press release / 4 October 2023
New database names companies blacklisted by global investors and banks
A coalition of NGOs today launched the Financial Exclusions Tracker, a new website that tracks which companies are being excluded by investors and banks for sustainability reasons. Most excluded corporations are barred due to links to fossil fuels, weapons or tobacco.
-
Event / 25 May 2023, 16:00 - 17:30
The Future We See: economic systems
What does an economy look like that serves the well-being of people and the planet?
A wide range of great ideas about a transition to sustainable and just economic systems already exist, including ways to get there and examples that show that it is really possible. In this talkshow, we highlight some of these examples and hope to fuel the dialogue about this topic.
Inspired? Join our 'The Future We See' - talkshow on May 25th! You can either attend live or online, quietly listen or actively participate in the discussion. We hope to see you there!
Get your free tickets for the liveshow (limited!) or to join online here!
-
Letter / 4 May 2023
Letter from NGOs to Dutch export credit agency: CSR policy must be strengthened
The Dutch government, through its export credit agency Atradius DSB (ADSB), provides export support to companies that undertake activities abroad. The state wants projects it insures to have no negative consequences for people and the environment and therefore sets requirements for corporate social responsibility (CSR). A consultation on CSR policy ran until the end of April, to which a coalition of thirteen social organisations from the Netherlands and abroad, including Both ENDS and Milieudefensie (Friends of the Earth the Netherlands), responded.
-
News / 18 April 2023
The Future We See - dialogues about sustainable and just global systems
In these uncertain times of accumulating national, international and global crises, we need hope and inspiration more than ever. Fortunately, many hopeful ideas and initiatives are already existing that show that it is indeed possible to change the world - and especially the systems behind it - in a sustainable and fair way. What opportunities are to be found, what is hopeful, what is already happening and how can we, as the Netherlands, respond to this?
-
Publication / 15 March 2023
-
Transformative Practice
Non-Timber Forest Products (NTFPs)
About one in every six people, particularly women, directly rely on forests for their lives and livelihoods, especially for food. This shows how important non-timber forest products (NTFPs) and forests are to ensure community resilience. Not only as a source of food, water and income, but also because of their cultural and spiritual meaning.
-
Publication / 4 November 2022
-
Publication / 4 November 2022
-
News / 4 November 2022
Both ENDS to attend climate conference in Egypt
Climate action is urgently needed to slow down global warming. The effects of climate change are already showing themselves. Floods in Pakistan and closer to us, in the Netherlands, are causing loss of life and much emotional and economic damage, while local climate solutions are still largely being ignored. That's why Both ENDS is going to participate in COP27, the climate conference in Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt.
-
Transformative Practice
Analog Forestry
Analog forestry is a transformative approach to the ecological restoration of degraded lands. Natural forests are used as guides to create ecologically sustainable landscapes, which support the social and economical needs of local communities.
-
Press release / 8 August 2022
Indigenous knowledge and languages crucial in the fight against climate change
Amsterdam, 8 August 2022 – In most countries around the world, the extensive knowledge of Indigenous peoples on nature, food, health, cultural traditions and Indigenous languages receives insufficient appreciation and attention in education and policy. The Indigenous-Led Education (ILED) Network believes that this must change. To mark the International Day of the World's Indigenous Peoples on 9 August, the ILED Network is calling for more support for the transfer of this Indigenous knowledge, which also plays a major role in resolving the biodiversity and climate crises.
-
Dossier
Uganda’s Energy Future
Despite the existence of many hydropower dams, foreign investments and large government spending on energy, and new plans for hydropower, oil and gas projects, the vast majority of rural Uganda still remains without electricity. Together with our local partners we are striving towards a sustainable energy strategy for Uganda that starts from the needs and wishes of local communities.
-
Press release / 25 May 2022
Award of export support for controversial project in Manilla undermines the Netherlands’ environmental and CSR ambitions
Dutch export credit agency Atradius DSB announced yesterday that it is to provide export credit insurance worth 1,5 billion euros to Dutch dredging company Boskalis for a controversial land reclamation project in the Philippines. According to Dutch and international organisations, including Both ENDS, CARE Netherlands, IUCN NL, Kalikasan PNE and Oceana Philippines, the award of export credit insurance for this project runs contrary to the Netherlands' ambitions in the areas of environment and corporate social responsibility (CSR).
-
News / 31 March 2022
Well-deserved recognition for small grants funds!
We are exited about the news that Ms MacKenzie Scott decided to entrust substantial funding to a wide range of small grants funds from Both ENDS' partner networks*. These small grants funds are unique as they are set up and led by people, often activists themselves, from the country or region in which the fund is based. Most mainstream conventional funders admit they have difficulties reaching community based organisations and grassroots groups themselves. Small grants funds know better than anyone how to reach local communities, who to support and what kind of financial as well as non-financial support is most needed. Thus, they bridge a wide funding gap. Both ENDS applauds this recognition of the important role of these funds in the funding landscape. We hope this encourages more funders to join!
-
Event / 22 February 2022, 16:00 - 17:30
Webinar and launch of new publication about EU-Mercosur
What is the EU-Mercosur association treaty and why is it controversial? What could be the implications of the treaty for people and their livelihoods both in EU and Mercosur countries? For more information about these and other issues, see our new publication and join our interactive webinar next week!
Register here